Pindar Cabernet Franc 2000 New York
Long Island (Peconic) ($15)
The way things have been going lately, I should probably just classify my blog as "wines not to buy." I don't like writing negative criticisms and I try to avoid passing sweeping judgments of a winery based on a single bottle. In this case I feel I should write something because I believe that people do make judgments of Long Island wines by the wine they can get their hands, which in most cases, is Pindar. Oh, and yeah, my girlfriend called me out on the subject with her last comment here. She gave me a lot of shite about bringing home an undrinkable wine with her hard earned $10.
Pindar Vineyards has a huge selection of wine. You can buy their wines on national online wine stores. If a local liquor store has one Long Island vineyard from which to choose, it's usually Pindar. I've visited the winery a few times and can't complain about their free tasting practices. It has the largest tasting area of any I have been to. When my girlfriend and I have been there, we are usually shoulder to shoulder with people who act they're on a frat party field trip. Anyway, the last time we were there, it was loud. Many high fives were given. I think I almost saw a couple cat fights break out -- seriously. We brought a friend that we know from our days at "The U" (of Miami) that was more interested in the pouring chick's low cut jeans, which left nothing to the imagination, than the wine. Needless to say we had polished off a bottle of Sauvignon Blanc ( yum! ) at Osprey's Dominion and biked ourselves from winery to winery already.
So. I had several of their reds and came to a conclusion that they all had this certain taste that identified them as Pindar. It's hard to pinpoint, but there was something that bled into each of the wines I tasted. The one I enjoyed the most was a non-vintage red blend called Pythagoras, a blend of Cab Sav, Cab Franc, Merlot, Petit Verdot and Malbec. It's low in tannins and seems to have a complexity that I do not expect in a medium to light bodied non-vintage blend. I found the Pythagoras for $10 at my "take fifty steps and make a right for fifteen more steps" NYC liquor store and was pleased with the price to enjoyment ratio.
The other night I went back to the same store with a $10 purchase on the mind. Turns out they had a Pindar Cabernet Franc 2000 for the same price. It lists for $15, so I thought that if it tasted half as good as other L.I. Cab Francs I've had, it would be well worth it. Surprise surprise.. I was wrong. It was turned. Poured it down the drain and opened a bottle from the cellar. It could be that the 2000 just can't be expected to age gracefully. Maybe the liquor store's storage methods leave something to be desired. Maybe it's just a bad wine, but I doubt it. Chances are you've already visited Lenn's Long Island vines, wines, and dines blog, but if not, go there forthwith to open your mind to the best L.I. has to offer.
Since I keep trying wines I've never had, I often take a chance and skip the wine I know I will enjoy. I guess it's just the risk I take for science. Not only that, my garage sale mentality of "hey, this bottle is only half its retail price" is not fit for the wine store. As I write this I am drinking a Red Hook ESB beer. At $1 a bottle it's so satisfying. Next week Astor Wines has a 25% off sale on Italian, German, French, Austrian and Greek wines. I am going to help them clear out some wines for their new store that opens next month. Any suggestions?
Recent Comments